

On October 18, 2026, The Straits Times published Martha Tara Lee’s opinion piece about married people using OnlyFans and dating apps. Lee argues that hidden behavior outside a couple’s agreement can breach trust without a physical affair.
The piece was updated on October 19, 2026, and The Straits Times Live repeated its argument that day. These are versions of one opinion built around a hypothetical dating-app example rather than separate research findings. They do not establish how common the behavior is or provide a detailed OnlyFans example.
The question Lee raises is still worth sitting with: when someone says nothing physical happened, have they answered the concern you actually brought up? Or has the conversation moved away from an agreement that mattered to you?
If you have found hidden messages or unexpected dating-app activity, this debate may feel painfully familiar. You might be trying to understand what happened. You might be trying to work out whether you are allowed to feel hurt at all.
The tiring part is having to argue for the right question. You ask about messages that crossed an agreement. The answer focuses only on whether anyone met in person.
Those are not identical questions. Lee’s argument leaves room for that difference without declaring every private interaction unfaithful. The agreement between the people in the relationship remains the point.
Public arguments about online behavior can make that conversation feel like a vote. One person calls everything harmless. Another calls every interaction a betrayal and expects you to leave immediately.
Neither response tells you what you and your partner agreed. Neither knows the full shape of your relationship. You do not have to make your experience fit the loudest opinion before speaking about it.
Our own experience includes electric chemistry alongside canceled plans and sudden mood shifts. A tearful conversation with a friend helped make that mismatch clear. The question we bring from that experience is whether the good moments are being used to close a conversation about the painful ones.
That question does not prove anything about hidden messages. It simply makes room for more than one truth: you can care deeply about someone and still need an honest answer from them.
In our experience, feeling numb in dating can reflect tiredness rather than bitterness. We support intentional breaks without guilt. Here that can mean stepping away from the debate rather than reading one more argument about what you should tolerate.
If you are caught between alarm and self-doubt, our writing on sorting worry from what you know offers another place to reflect. There is no need to settle every question about your future in one sitting.
In Lee’s example, a married person downloads a dating app “just for a look.” Swiping and messaging follow. The later defense rests on the absence of a physical affair.
Notice the change in focus. The explanation does not address every part of the behavior described. It answers the narrow question of physical contact.
Our view is that a profile or a flattering exchange should not be mistaken for real intimacy. Presenting yourself to someone online is not the same as building a relationship with them. Yet that does not make concealed messaging meaningless within an existing agreement.
We would separate the performance from the responsibility. An online interaction need not become a lasting connection to raise a question about a promise. Equally, the existence of an interaction does not tell us every intention behind it.
Lee’s agreement-based argument offers a useful place to begin: the behavior itself. App use and messaging are different from proof of an in-person meeting. Keeping that distinction does not require dismissing the behavior that is known.
For your own reflection, it may help to separate three questions:
These are editorial prompts rather than a test that produces a verdict. Their purpose is to keep the conversation close to the concern. They leave room to say that something hurt without claiming knowledge you do not have.
You can name hidden messaging without claiming a physical affair occurred. You can ask about an agreement without pretending to know every motive. You can leave an unanswered question unanswered for now.
A broad promise to be faithful may not explain what either person means by online behavior. Lee’s argument points back to the particular couple’s agreement rather than a rule for every relationship.
Possible conversation topics include dating-app use and romantic messaging. Paid content and disclosure may matter to your agreement too. These are prompts for discussion rather than a checklist taken from Lee’s article.
The aim is not to make every couple choose the same limits. It is to make the expectations clear enough to discuss honestly.
At Uncrumb, we help people tired of conversations with strangers that never become meetings set clearer boundaries and ask about meeting sooner. The belief behind that work applies here: clarity does not require coldness. Naming an expectation is different from expecting someone to guess it.
If an expectation was never discussed, that deserves an honest conversation. It does not require pretending the hurt is absent. It means separating the expectation you held from the agreement you both understood.
Our Boundary Scripts Library offers word-for-word texts for difficult conversations. In that same spirit, the examples here give language to a concern without claiming to know what happened in your relationship.
Where an agreement was clear, possible wording is:
> “We agreed not to message potential dates. The messages crossed that agreement. I want us to talk about that rather than only whether you met anyone.”
Where expectations were never spoken aloud, the wording can leave that difference visible:
> “I thought we shared the same understanding about dating apps. We have not actually talked about it clearly. I want to explain what I expected and hear what you understood.”
Neither script requires you to make an accusation about a physical affair. Neither asks you to deny the behavior that concerns you. The purpose is a clearer conversation rather than a perfectly phrased sentence that controls someone’s response.
There is no wording that guarantees a satisfying answer. We believe the words can still be useful when they help you say what you mean without abandoning what you know.
In Lee’s framing, the relevant question is whether concealed behavior fell outside the couple’s agreement. A response about physical contact may address part of the situation. It may leave that agreement untouched.
Our editorial suggestion is to notice whether the conversation returns to the concern you named. Are you discussing the messages and the agreement? Or are you repeatedly defending your right to bring them up?
In our work, we help people distinguish healthy space during conflict from silence used as punishment. We guide people to name a punishing pattern once and set a time limit. Chronic punishing silence is a strong signal that leaving may need to be part of their thinking.
That is guidance about a recurring pattern rather than a verdict on one quiet moment. It belongs beside the online question, not in place of it. The way a concern is handled deserves attention too.
Our guide to patterns you keep explaining away offers more room for that reflection. You do not need to collect a larger accusation before looking honestly at a repeated response that hurts.
The bottom line is not that everyone must share the same rules about online behavior. Lee’s argument is narrower: the absence of a physical affair does not automatically settle whether a couple’s agreement was broken.
You can take that question seriously without taking on every label attached to modern dating. You do not need to join a public argument about what strangers permit. Your relationship is not a comment section that needs a winning side.
For us, a gentler approach leaves room for clear agreements and honest uncertainty. It does not shame you for loving someone. It does not judge the messages you wish you had not sent or demand that you make a decision before you are ready.
There is room for a calmer conversation about dating than the one that asks you to keep proving your worth. You can close the debate for tonight and return to the question that is actually yours.
With care, Uncrumb. There is no need to keep up with every dating trend.
Uncrumb is a calm space for honest relationship advice. Follow us for new guides, small reminders and gentle support when love feels confusing.
A new study links attachment profiles with problematic social-media use. A gentle look at the findings without turning scrolling into a label.
Continue reading